Of course, if the old cartridge is still working, and you want to use it up first, you'll just have to take the risk that the new one won't

Not until i ripped the cartridge out and replaced it with a new new one did it work

I think I will be heading back to the less expensive regular cartridges that seem to last just as long

My printer is working just fine with other ink, so this cartridge was a total rip off and I would never buy from this seller again.

Printer says the cartridge is not in right

I am now receiving an error from my printer that the product is not the right cartridge for this printer.

This cartridge was either defective or a counterfeit.

I cleaned cartridges, aligned the printer, and cleaned smears for hours trying to get it to work

Brand new cartridge and and still 3/4 filled and will not print in black no matter how many times I clean the head.

This meant that I could not return the defective cartridge and get a refund.

The cartridge is expensive

I tried to align, clean cartridge, clean printer heads, and nothing stopped the streaking when printing.

My printer (HP OfficeJet 4650) says this cartridge is incompatible!

Printed several pages then got error message that cartridge was incompatible with my printer

Great cartridge

No problem with printer telling you that it is not a genuine HP cartridge

Cartridge arrived on time and works like a charm!

Never had an issue with authentic HP ink cartridges.

Cartridge is no good

I always buy extra cartridges of ink when my present ink runs out - I put the fresh ink cartridge I have (in waiting) into the printer and then order another fresh cartridge.

That has never happened to me before with genuine HP ink cartridges.

I love my HP black ink cartridge.

Fifty dollars later with the wrong size ink cartridge, I ordered the correct cartridge.

I put this review to warn you that if you are buying ink, only buy it if you are going to use it immediately, otherwise you could get a dead cartridge and not be able to return or exchange it

When I installed my new 63Xl ink and printer said defective cartridge

great cartridge and great service!!

This cartridge was defective

I continued to work with it, trying different settings, etc until my printer rejected the cartridge completely and refused to operate until I removed it

On both cartridges at about the 50% point, my printer showed an error message telling me the cartridges were not compatible with my printer.

Just opened it today and inserted it and got error message that the cartridge has a problem

The right ink cartridge for my printer and at a competitive price.

Excellent ink cartridge,

I won't purchase again from you again as I think you are sending faulty cartridges out.

The printer didn't seem to recognize the cartridge, and after many attempts with a HP tech support rep, we determined that the cartridge was defective.

I don't know if this is even genuine ink cartridge but it gave me very very bad quality, faded and fuzzy black text.

I prefer the 63XL black cartridge over the standard 63.

Outstanding cartridge

After an hour with HP they determined it was a bad cartridge and are sending another one.

I've cleaned the cartridges, twice

I took all the steps to calibrate the cartridge, clean, and try to get the ink to work but no luck

Defective cartridge.

As usual, as with all the HP products that I have purchased, the cartridge is excellent.

Both cartridges worked for the first 50% of the ink level, but then failed.

Appreciate the High Yield Cartridge

Great ink cartridge.

Both cartridges worked for the first 50% of the ink level, but then failed.

In this case, the cartridge failed on installation.

I wonder if this is a genuine HP printer cartridge.

The perfect cartridge.

Bad cartridge

Defective cartridge, skipped lines on paper, attempted to return to

Received a defective cartridge and returned it to them the next day

This cartridge did not work straight out of the box

I have cleaned the cartridges multiples times (under the Tools menu), but when I took them out to clean them, I saw that the nozzle plate (where the ink comes out) was much bigger on the replacement cartridge than on the original cartridge

Original cartridges always work.

These appear to be the correct cartridges, but I was thrown off because they did not arrive in any packaging other than the plastic tear away bag around each individual cartridge

i put the 1st one in and within a week i got a warning message that this was a knock off and fake hp cartridge

Only use genuine HP cartridges for HP printers

CARTRIDGE WORKS GREAT NOT CLOTTING.

The cartridge installed easily and worked with no glitches.

Good cartridge

Or is this the new normal for HP?i may try some cheap (non HP) cartridges to see if i get better results

She kept trying to blame the printer and the problem was the ink cartridge that I bought for $42.....bad cartridge

This cartridge has no ink in it, and because I like to buy things ahead of

And yes, this cartridge is the recommended one for my printer.

My HP4650 gave a message that this is an incompatible cartridge even though that printer is listed on the box.

The cartridge did not work—defective

Inserted the last cartridge on 2/8 and the printer says it’s not a compatible cartridge

Great ink cartridges, fair price, but they do not last as long as the cartridges that I pay an arm and a leg for!

I'd recommend to anyone NOT to buy the 63 - they DO NOT LAST long and we all know how expensive printer ink cartridges are

This is not a genuine HP ink cartridge.

HP is a silly, stupid, sob company block this cartridge to be used in Brazil

after only using 20% of ink the HP printer sent a error message saying the the cartridge was not compatible with the printer

My printer would not accept this as an authentic HP cartridge.

I eventually got it to work, but will prefer new cartridges in the future.

Like the long-lasting cartridge

Original cartridge, works as expected.

not had any defective cartridges

The cartridge was for my printer and it works like a dream

Excellent cartridge, but far too expensive

With this cartridge in the printer, the printer will not print and gives an alert message that an incompatible cartridge has been installed.

Prefer this XL type cartridge.

The cartridge would not work in my printer even though it is the one indicated for it.

This cartridge failed.

Put in this brand new and very expensive cartridge and it worked fine for a few pages

I got much fewer pages from this than the cheaper regular cartridge!!Not worth the money!

Unfortunately, I lost approximately $60.00 on the bad ink cartridges.

Just wish the cartridges weren't so expensive and would last longer.

and it was a "bad" cartridge

I find that HP will not warrant the failed cartridge since it was purchased through Amazon.

I bought this and installed it correctly and the printer says the cartridge is incompatible, I had to go out and buy another one, I would like a refund

Had to go out and buy a new cartridge so printer would work

Expensive cartridges but last quite a while

I prefer the XL cartridges, they last a long time, the print quality is great.

Original cartridges work without problems.

Cartridge faulty.

Has a monthly ink program that is WAY CHEAPER.I am now on that plan, plus they gave me two free cartridges for joining

I called HP and they sent free ink cartridges, black and color.

Tried "Cartridge cleaning" - crickets

FAKE HP cartridges do not buy!

2 fresh cartridges in a row were not recognized by HP printer and would not print black ink on paper.

Great print cartridge.

It's better to buy the regular cartridges on sale than risk it with one of these.

Cartridge was defective, didn't print one single sheet.

Great ink cartridge

Cartridge does not work, don't by this rip off

installed the 2nd cartridge, and it works fine

It's ink, it worked as it should.

Expensive, but works as it should.

Good as what I order from HP themselves.

Boys and girls, ladies and gents.... peace of mind that a product is going to perform as well as or better than promised is PRICELESS!

n’t work very dissatisfied with product

n’t work very dissatisfied with product