Always get the perfect wing with this eyeliner and it doesn’t dry out on me like others that I’ve tried before

Always get the almost perfect wing with that great point at the end if the swipe👌 😍

It has a super fine tip, great for precision, anyone can create a nice wing

The brush is perfect for getting a good wing, and the formula is the best I’ve ever seen from a drug store eyeliner

The brush liner tip is sharper/finer than the Kat Von D one, which makes it easier to get that fine line wing

Pros of the product is that it has easy application and it’s a good price

Great price for a product that works, a waste of money for dried out trash.

It's easy to apply a very, the pen is small and easy to use which is great for detail and the price is definitely affordable for a product I use all too often.

Not worth the cheaper price.

Overall I’m impressed with the pen with its smooth lines, lasting power and cheap price

This liner is super easy to use and I love how soft and thin it is

This is a great liner, right up until you miss the hole inside the cap and you fray the tip of the liner.

This liner falls short of my expectations and I do not recommend

This is a good liner, and for me a great value and good product

I don’t recommend this eye liner because it will take a while for the product to give a great finish.

Literally has no liquid coming out and the tip of the pen is so flimsy that its hard to actually draw on your eye lids.

The tip is also perfect because it's not super stiff where it would hurt your eyelids when you press down, but it's got just enough stiffness to draw the line

It’s super pigmented and the tip is so easy to use and create my cat eye look!

The tip hardened and dried mdespite being capped properly

It has a super fine tip, great for precision, anyone can create a nice wing

IF I am going to wear eyeliner it needs to be a really fine line

The value is unmatchedLove the fine sharp dark line I get

The brush liner tip is sharper/finer than the Kat Von D one, which makes it easier to get that fine line wing

But with this, the application is crisp, the line is dark and the longevity is impressive

Overall, this is a great eyeliner, no skip, easy to get a clean line.

This is the WORST eyeliner I’ve ever used

I like this product much better than others I have used

To my amazement it was as good if not better then any eyeliner I've used in the past

First use of this eyeliner was decent, tip dries up very

the brush tip is so thin, and gets fatter towards the back, but the coolest part is that the brush tip is harder than most bristles used in eyeliners

Ladies, this another great product I purchased, and I love it!

The product is easy to use, and was very black on the one

If a gel eyeliner brush is your go-to, this could be a great product for you

it is smudge proof other words cheap and garbage product

Love the product itself but disappointed I could not use after a week it dried out.

I have to say, I am impressed by Mabelline's New York hyper easy liquid pen eyeliner.

after 1 day this pen is useless

Great pen and eyeliner, most of the ones I try get dry so quick

I’m new to wearing eyeliner but this pen makes it so easy

The product is a great, well-designed pen that makes it easy to hold.

I didn't expect much but this is such great eye liner for its value

It was a very nice eye liner the first day, then the next day I went go use it, it was all dried up.

This is a great eye liner I was crying at a funeral and my eye liner stayed in place

This is a great eye liner but it doesn't last as long as I would want it too.

If I even lay on my side my eyes will start watering so waterproof is very important to me or I will not buy it

n’t snapped the lid well

suave la puedes hacer más

Your browser does not support HTML5 video.

n’t think I recommend this.

I like using brush or pen liners because you can get a really good thin tail on a winged eyeliner

Also, the brush is flexible like the KVD liner (which I hate

And the brush is firm not flimsy/floppy like some eyeliner brushes

The thin brush is perfect for drawing out your eyeliner, and it's lasted me a while

I would give this a 4 1/2 star review as the brush hairs would fall out or the brush would become stiff and hard to use.

Your browser does not support HTML5 video.

suave la puedes hacer más

Can withstand a shower and only smudges a bit if you fall asleep with it on

n’t snapped the lid well

It did smudge a bit on the upper part of my eyelid since my double eyelid doesn't go fully

Pretty good quality, does tend to bleed a bit on the eyes but if you are careful and work with it a bit it is pretty good!

Pretty good quality, does tend to bleed a bit on the eyes but if you are careful and work with it a bit it is pretty good!

but I’ll have to keep looking for a smudge proof eyeliner

Not smudge proof or waterproof

While it obviously isn't as strong as my favorite life proof Asian eyeliners, its still very affordable and may work beautifully for the majority of people

It's lightweight, smudge proof, easy to apply, and last all day

Super easy to glide, totally water and smudge proof, as it says

The cap does not stay on and there before even using it, the pen tip was so dry and hard it scratched my eyelid.

Not only does this smudge immediately when I put it on, the worst part is that it makes my eyelids feel sticky.

My eyelids are slightly "crepy" and have fine lines and slight wrinkles which tend to mess me up when using liquid eyeliner on my top lid, but this one actually works well for me

The tip is also perfect because it's not super stiff where it would hurt your eyelids when you press down, but it's got just enough stiffness to draw the line

My eyelids have wrinkles