After reading reviews on the commuter series and how many poor reviews it got

I bought this case after reading numerous positive reviews

Delete your unhelpful and biased review.

I'm not sure what the hell the bad (one star) reviews are about

so I can't really give a good review

In short, I haven't been able to substantiate a single one of the negative reviews.

I can't figure out all the negative reviews, but what pushed me over the top to order was Otterbox's response to each of the negative reviews

excellent I liked this product

good i like it