I rated this 4 stars because I do not know about the pain relief.

Pain relief is hard to tell since she can't talk, but she'll still chase coyotes

I gave the pain relief 3 stars just because I do not know

Our dog loves the flavor I can notice she has pain relief

Seems to work for him over time giving him some pain relief.

Honestly, I cannot say enough amazing things about these little magic chews

and I see visible change in her comfort level which is the most important thing to me

The most important thing is she actually likes this and she takes it as a treat with no issues, so it is super easy to administer

n’t have any joint problems right now because he’s a young

My 11 year old 80# boxer/pit/mastiff is very picky and rarely likes treats but she loves these things

I was thrilled to find this at such a great price that she actually eats!

It's really working for dog, I am amazed by the product and the affordable price.

I cannot believe the magic of these vitamins and for such a great price

Luckily the price wa slow enough that I don't feel I was ripped off just because they didn't work for my pet.

Love these for my dog who has DM , the price is so affordable as well

Again, I stays that one should be given time for items bought for a good review.

I ordered this product because it contained Glucosamine and had good reviews

Bought these after reading reviews hoping it would work for my english bulldog.

The reviews are correct on this one two of my dogs have problems with their back legs

The reviews hyped it up so I thought it would

The chews are very hard from being out of container, so throwing all away and try to find something else

The chews won’t cure my 14 year old pet’s joint issues but he does seem to be walking better

The chews were hard, not chewy, and upset my dog's stomach

She has arthritis so giving her one of the hip and joint soft chews has made her life easier

That being said, the chews arrived very soft, and fresh smelling, and he loved the piece he had before it made him sick.

This product makes my dog sick even after eating her food.

I love this product, works great for my 7 year old dog who was starting to get stiff and loosing his enthusiasm to run an play

This product does not work for my 107lbs Great Pyrenees

My dog had been spitting it out and that’s when we realized the product was expired and clearly spoiled.

I can't rate this product because my dog did not like, and would not eat the chews

Our dog loves the flavor I can notice she has pain relief

Our dog loves the flavor and it seems to be helping his pain

The 10 year old doesn’t like the flavor, so I hide it in his food

She loves the flavor and gobbles them up as treats each night

Also apparently the flavor is nasty because he spits out the

she loves the taste taking it readily would highly recommend!

My poor pup absolutely hates the taste and wont eat them

My dog loves the taste and it perks her 11 year old body right up!

so you will need to keep it up and where the dog cannot get to it like actual medicine.my dog loves the taste so

One of our dogs didn't like the taste but the other one will eat just about anything

My dog loves these little treats that are good for him!

By the way, the fact that they are so soft is very important for older dogs, since they often have problems chewing harder treats for a variety of reasons.

n’t have any joint problems right now because he’s a young

Either way, for us these have just been expensive treats.

But with this...he usually he will refuse to eat all the other joint relief, pain relief, vitamin benefit-related treats

n’t have any joint problems right now because he’s a young

I had tried a vet recommended joint supplement as well as another joint supplement I found on

The chews won’t cure my 14 year old pet’s joint issues but he does seem to be walking better

But for a dog with minor, typical aging joints, this supplement is wonderful!

I also give her Nutra Thrive supplement every morning as

Our dog loves the flavor I can notice she has pain relief

This is a great product, my dog was experiencing pain just climbing the

My dog was having major pain in his hip and was having a hard time getting up to stand/walk.

I would recommend these if your dog is having issues with pain and mobility.

My dog had been limping and having hip discomfort for some

n’t have any joint problems right now because he’s a young

n’t have any joint problems right now because he’s a young

Since we have started giving him the PetNC Natural Care Hip and Joint Soft Chews he has not had any pain in his hips.

We decided to try this product several months ago when our adopted beagle mix (now 10 years old) started having problems with one of her front legs

The chews won’t cure my 14 year old pet’s joint issues but he does seem to be walking better

n’t have any joint problems right now because he’s a young

n’t feeling so hot

His arthritis has improved a lot.

n’t say much how the product works

The chews won’t cure my 14 year old pet’s joint issues but he does seem to be walking better

She takes a pain pill and anti inflammatory pill daily and these are great to smoosh around the pills

Happy w the product just wish it was a lil cheaper ;p

My elderly yorkie refused ALL joint pills

she likes the taste and therefore trusts me giving them to her, they are also soft enough to wrap medication in as I tried that with her because I couldn’t get her to take her prescribed pill, but I tried it and she takes her pill every other day as well with no problems.

This pills definitely work

I saw several reviews saying their dog had a bad reaction and threw

SEVERE ALLERGIC REACTION!!My poor pup had a mouth completely covered in blisters!

n’t clear up

Vet said it was the worst allergic reaction she has ever seen!!!BUYER BEWARE!

We will be trying our lab on this soon as well, but since her reaction was worse than his with the costco, we waited to see how the springer did

n’t say much how the product works

The chews won’t cure my 14 year old pet’s joint issues but he does seem to be walking better

My pibble is 11 and she started having mobility issues... hard to climb up stairs and run.

I would recommend trying for older dogs with mobility issues.

n’t feeling so hot

He moves a bit easier as well.

My 10 year old chihuahua/Jack Russell, Miss Cora, was starting to stumble a bit

I cut it into 4 pieces (yes, they a very small pieces) to make him slow down a little bit.

n’t feeling so hot

n’t clear up

Are they effective only time will tell as this is my first purchase of this brand.

She is old and was having a hard time with stairs and walks

My dog was having major pain in his hip and was having a hard time getting up to stand/walk.

My pomeranian had issues with her hip and had a hard time walking

The product is great, however, this time it arrived with the lid off, the sealed part open, and product all spilled out, and all over the bottom of the box!

n’t say much how the product works

Two of my dogs tend to be picky eaters, but one eats anything well until these

Also, he is such a picky treat eater, but gobbles these up like it’s his last meal

My dog is super picky eater but he loves this product lol

She's a very picky eater and usually doesn't even take most vitamins well.

My Chihuahua has hip problems and this has helped him a lot

I bought these for my older pup who has been having some hip problems - which has been causing some movement difficulty for him

Happy w the product just wish it was a lil cheaper ;p

My 4 y o pup has had some hip problems over the last couple of years

My dog was having hip problems and could do stairs or jump up on the couch

We adopted a 5 year old dog who had bad hip pain and would limp really bad after very short walks

I will continue to keep him on this supplement as maintenance and preventive of future hip pain.

If you want your dog to suffer less hip pain, I highly encourage you to buy this product

Happy w the product just wish it was a lil cheaper ;p

Happy w the product just wish it was a lil cheaper ;p

Gave her two (following the recommendations on the carton) and she had dark explosive diarrhea, twice in the last month

but it has given my poor Jack Russell horrible diarrhea for days

Two half doses has resulted in explosive diarrhea to the point that I think we will be making a vet trip soon if it

You know, to help clean up all the diarrhea.

Nothing has ever given my dog bloody diarrhea before and if I had given him more, he would probably be in the hospital right now

The chews won’t cure my 14 year old pet’s joint issues but he does seem to be walking better

These have helped my dog as he has started having hip issues

The chews won’t cure my 14 year old pet’s joint issues but he does seem to be walking better

Our 8 year old yellow lab began having hip issues which are not bad enough for surgery but seem to cause her stiffness and some discomfort especially after a long weekend trying to keep up with our 2 year old "grand" dog.

Happy w the product just wish it was a lil cheaper ;p