However, if you like the iPod / iTunes philosophy, then this could be an excellent choice for you.

For my wife who loves listening to music, the Classic proved to be the right choice

The Classic offers about 15 times the memory for the same price, so it is certainly a better choice if you have a decent sized music library

It was the perfect choice for me

This a replacement for my 4 year old 30G Classic iPod which died after spending 4 years in a hot car i the south Florida sun