So I take both of them in and, low and behold, the second disk is in worse condition than the first

Disc was good condition and box and

Game disk is in excellent condition, and the booklet and game case look almost brand new.

Game in decent condition but there is mold growing in between the pages of the manual, some people are deathly allergic to mold

There were scratches on the disc, but the only thing they seem to have affected up is the opening cutscene that appears before the menu, & the manual was a bit faded, but still colorful & in otherwise decent condition

The game is in great condition

gave me an acceptable disk when he claimed it was good condition

The case was in good condition, but the game did not work.

Great Condition And