The ends are easy for him to hold at 7 months old and the rattle makes enough noise that he doesn't get bored with it to quickly.

The noise encourages them to shake and experiment

The rattle noise is too quiet

I give it a 4-star because I would appreciate it if the noise it made were a little louder (maybe I'm crazy

Does not make a loud enough noise

Its easy for him to hold and the rattle noise kepshim entertaiined.

and she definitely enjoys the noise!

It doesn't make too much of a rattle noise but our 3mo old is easily able to grasp both the ends of the rattle and the center spoke and hold on well.

The noise is not too loud, but loud enough that she loves shaking it around

Doesn’t make a loud noise like a traditional rattle though.

It makes a little noise when she shakes

Our baby liked it early on because of the rattling noise it made

The noise is not too loud, but loud enough that she loves shaking it around

Doesn’t make enough noise to keep the baby entertained!

Does not make a loud enough noise

It makes some light noise when he shakes

The rattle noise is too quiet

It amuses the daughter yet not too loud that the noise is annoying

The noise encourages them to shake and experiment

Can use Bigger plastic balls to make more rattling noise.

The ends are easy for him to hold at 7 months old and the rattle makes enough noise that he doesn't get bored with it to quickly.

They are not obnoxious like other musical toys but good for teaching kids to grip and shaking noise is pleasant!

Its very cute, for teething its a little hard due to it having the holes, the rattle noise is not loud

Easy to grasp and makes a quiet but audible shaking noise.

so it makes a light suttle rattle noise

She loves the noise and sticking her tongue in the holes.

/o still loves it.

My son likes o play with this toy, easy to grab and makes noises, so keeps him busy.

He loves all O

Not as noisy as the other rattle I