The holster broke within minutes of taking it out of the package when I climbed into my

The holster that you use to hang on your belt is fragile.

The clip holding the holster to your belt or purse strap broke *the very first

I do not like the new holster though

Holster is sturdy and case enclosure is protective.

The holster was also uncomfortable to wear

I have bought quite a few Otterbox Defender series case and holsters and the holster clip breaks within a few months on at least 1/3 of them.

The problem I have with Otterbox is the holster that accompanies the defender series case

There is a fundamental design flaw that increases the chances of breaking the holster and you may want to consider buying another holster with a different design.

If I were to be honest tho, every time I broke a holster, it was my fault

the holster was easy to use and convenient

Overall, the otter box defender case for the i phone five s is super strong and durable!