For some people who complained that the targeting was difficult, if you double-tap the L2 button, the game does a great job of locking right on to the target - actually almost too good of a job

This game has done a great job of pulling me in and keeping me there.

R* also did an excellent job of making the West alive with animals and diverse geography.

Story does a great job of building up to multiple climaxes

It's obvious RDR wants to immerse you in it's world, and it does a decent job in doing so, but having to watch a large amount of cuts scenes that display your character talking for you despite how your actions play out when you're in control of him is weak

I believe that Rockstar did an excellent job with this game.

Rock Star games does a really good job of keeping a solid character together in John Marston, who is a former outlaw who is forced to do the governments dirty work in order to save his family from them

Also they don't do a great job explaining the whole horses stamina thing, or Dead Eye and how it works, the manual is almost worthless, it looks nice but its 5 pages long and not that full of info, but high its full color right?Here's a couple quick tips, the blue bar in the left is your horse stamina

RDR does an amazing job of bringing this fantasy to life.

Its a really good character driven game, which does a really good job in sucking you into the story

Overall great job by rockstar for the gameplay and story.

Mostly, Rockstar has done a fine job in creating this world

Rockstar has done an EXCELLENT job with this game and has supplied us gamers with a western that is sure to be legendary within the community of gamers and Red Dead is a place that I can go and roam the western desert and do whatever I decide.

This is easily the best western game ever produced, and Rockstar has done an outstanding job

great job, rockstar. was never a huge fan of the GTA franchise but you've got me now with this one

They really did a good job all around, from the landscape to the towns.

Rockstar really did a good job with this game

They do a darn good job of making you feel as if you have been dropped into the post Civil War TexMex Boarder.

Waypoints on both a physical and software map do a great job of guiding you across the hills and mountains.

Furthermore, Rockstar does a great job of showing Marston's motivation for things he does, which furthers the great story in ways many games nowadays just can't

The Fugly:First, the game does a HORRIBLE job of showing you how to do anything.

Not to mention GoHastings did a great job shipping it

" o superior, por lo demas es un muy buen juego interminable