There's multiplayer in both games as well, but I don't play them (though I've heard they're fun)

the online multiplayer is addicting specially the COOP mode (require downloading a free DLC)PROS:+ addicting game "challenges, free roaming"+ great story

Multiplayer is just bad

What we're left with is a genuinely fun, interesting, unique title that is brimming with content that could easily eat up hundreds of hours, not even including the multiplayer and newly released (free) co-op DLC

The multiplayer is solid

A less ambitious multiplayer, maybe a smaller world that kept the players closer together with more to do then shoot each other or hordes of random Mexicans, would have been really cool.

If you like multiplayer more, maybe not

In free roam, multiplayer, you need to be careful because anyone can kill anyone else at any time

enough said.this game has excellent online multiplayer offerings

Multiplayer is limited.

Sooooo glad i didIt playes like GTA but with horses and lassos and the multiplayer is really fun

I haven't touched the (reportedly buggy) multiplayer yet, but with as much fun as I'm having just riding around rescuing people from bandits and trying to avoid becoming a cougar's lunch, I haven't missed it at all

The Multiplayer is pretty cool and has a lot of depth to it.

Much like in GTA, the character mechanics are not polished enough for competitive multiplayer

And multiplayer, of course if you enjoy multiplayer

the multiplayer is pretty fun and challenging too as well

Multiplayer is simply stunning - I find myself staying in the free roam "lobby" more often than not, PVPing and working on gang hideouts, and the leveling system offers some nice perks, while keeping gameplay from being too out of balance.

Excellent multiplayer modes

Also has a good multiplayer.

The multiplayer is fun, however, it can get quite boring

Add on a robust multiplayer mode with both competitive and cooperative modes similar to that of

Great history and grafics counts with a solid multiplayer

AMAZING multiplayer

Multiplayer wise its pretty good as well

Multiplayer wise its pretty good as well

multiplayer is fun and engaging, plus the co-op is a good challenge

The multiplayer is pretty weak.

However once this and the original game are over, players are left with only the multiplayer experience or the boring redundancy of single player without any drive or focus.

While the single player is AMAZING, the multiplayer still lacks.

If you don't like multiplayer, don't worry, singleplayer is more than worth the price alone

Multiplayer is fun and addictive.

Excellent online multiplayer and private game modes.

The Good:-Great, compelling storyline-Lots and lots of activities, games, and side quests-Beautiful landscape-Top notch soundtrack-Fun multiplayer-New honor system and wanted system is fantasticThe Bad:-A few glitches here and thereOverall, this game is amazing

I'd suggest to wait to for price drop and wait for a patch because multiplayer has many issues

i mean comeon 20-40 hours of gameplay for 60 dollars (40 if u preorder and got the 20 dollar gift card =]) with a great multiplayer that will last another 2 months =]; in the game there are so many side quest and things to do u get sidetracked

I give 4 stars because the multiplayer has some bugs

i can say for a fact that i hate gta4, despite its high reviews it wasnt that kind of game for me, but this game isnt just gta4 with horsies, it is fun, good looking, great sotry, and multiplayer was better than i expectedabout the game

If you like multiplayer more, maybe not

Good number of enjoyable multiplayer options.

I would recommend this game for its originality, great gameplay, cool cut-scenes, great story and a decent multiplayer mode.

Multiplayer is fun, as it has the same 3rd person feel in familiar locations.

Multiplayer is great and your friends have a chance to revive you when you die so its great to play and keeps you engaged even after you die, hoping you will be revived

It has a great single player with a lot of different things to do, and the online multiplayer is great too!

Multiplayer is like getting an entire other game for free.

Amazing graphics+ online multiplayer and

There is no other game out there like it, single player is as good as multiplayer and they have dlc already coming

if you love GTA type of games, this will blow your mind out!!!it's fantastic!!!multiplayer also

I love the multiplayer, although there may not be too many people that still play it.

I was impress by graphics, gameplay and story of this adventure game its a jewel a must play for gamers, if you are looking for excelent single player campaing and good multiplayer lasting appeal you have it in red dead redemption

multiplayer doesn't work anymore but this game is still awesome.

Furthermore, the multiplayer is awsome, if you want to be a cowboy, you can ride horses in a free roam world, use turn of the century guns, and if you get the dlc (downloadable content) you can play poker/liars dice, fight zombies, and much more

There was a potential to make it a better multiplayer experience, however the free roam and the attempt of a gang war or whatever is that they had in mind failed miserably

Basically it's amazing how many things there are to do, and belive me, they all work really well and are fun.-Multiplayer(10/10): You can use the entire singleplayer map in free roam multiplayer

so overall the wow factor really made me like this game.everything about the graphics, gameplay, multi, and story wows me; nothing like wat i expectedmy only bad comment is that u can;t change controls, and the game forces u to use r2 and l2 for trigger and aim, which isnt bad, but can be bothersome for those use to use l1 and r1, but i admit it is fun using those triggers now and it makes me went to buy those ps3 real r2 and l triggerso my advice, buy this game if u like a shooter with length, story, graphics, the only hate u can have is that u hate horsies and western stuff

as i over look that issue the game is fun enough to get a solid 5, but for me that cheating issue is terrible

The game is a tremendous value as well as it seems like it will end several times but keeps going providing a ton of gameplay

The story unravels as you play and discover more of what is going on in the West in 1911.

On the PS3 Graphic Report Card, this gets a solid A+ and could be the best looking game of 2010.Sound_______________________________________________________________________The music is perfect, and the score is so fitting for every scene

I would definitely recommend the game, but would also recommend to buy the fastest horse in the game as soon as you can

I have to compliment R* for the depth of the experience and characters in the game.

I'd also like to see something in the form of bosses as opposed to set pieces, but R* will have to clean up their controls, which compared to say Mass Efeect are good, but any AAA action game, suck

My personal opinion, RDR is the best R* game ever

I'd also like to see something in the form of bosses as opposed to set pieces, but R* will have to clean up their controls, which compared to say Mass Efeect are good, but any AAA action game, suck