That said, I loved Rockstar's GTA IV

and I applaud Rockstar for doing it

Rockstar, you could have eased up a bit.

I would do one mission and go hunting for 2 hours or just ride my horse around and look at the beautiful creation Rockstar made

Rockstar is a the top of their game with this gem.

Thank you Rockstar

It's one of the best games Rockstar has ever come out with

This is for real gamers who like a challenge in muliplayer and in single player and who love rockstar and just love games in general

Rockstar didn't take advantage of the full landscape, leaving some areas almost entirely untouched by the single player mode when they could have added some great

Rockstar had it rough trying to make a mostly empty environment seem interesting, and they did well

you lost a lot of sales because of this, rockstar.

Good job rockstar

Thank you Rockstar for making another must-own game.

Rockstar took the good from its Grand Theft Auto series & nearly perfected it.

Each of these games have their own perks, but none of them come close to Rockstar's Red Dead Redemption

Rockstar San Diego has added an additional classic to the dying genre

Rockstar did well with this one

Great job Rockstar!

Overall, Rockstar's finally won me over with this one and even though I hate sequels, I hope they keep this world going.

Marston, while certainly not a white-hat wearing saint, is certainly more akin to the traditional hero than the stars of prior epics to come out of the Rockstar stable

Rockstar has taking the GTA game engine and done wonders.

Best Rockstar game to date

This game is right next to San Andreas as my favorite Rockstar Game.

Also, Rockstar fails for making you immediatly glow on the map as soon as you respawn.

Thank You Rockstar!For aiming - there is an auto target system that works when you are pointing within reasonable proximity of a target

Rockstar can claim to have made this game realistic, but when you can't get away with a couple murders out in the wasteland, then it's pointless and makes you not want to do it

Can't fault Rockstar on the audio side and the voice acting is excellent

As of today (September 2014), still the best Rockstar game and I even like the GTA series

Rockstar failed on this one.

Rockstar has a reputation for making sandbox games that are nothing short of phenominal...but a cowboy game?

Through this game and the Grand Theft Auto series, Rockstar have proven their title as the master of the open-world game.

This game is nothing short of perfect, quite possibly the best Rockstar game yet

With Red Dead Redemption, Rockstar has done what many modern gaming companies fail to do: give the customer their money's worth

I have yet to play a Rockstar game that I didn't like.

Rockstar really did good on this

Fun, fun game, but shorter then the typical Rockstar, "Grand Theft Auto" game

Rockstar has never failed the video game industry yet and they continue satisfy my gaming needs with this game

Rockstar knocked this one out of the park, and the fans have been begging for more ever since

As a good rockstar games you can kill, thief, gamble, etc

Rockstar finally took a break from their classic IP, Grand Theft Auto, to build a Western game like no other

I agree with other reviewers that it is the best Rockstar game.

Another great rockstar game great textures and gameplay

I absolutely love open world games and Rockstar has produced some of the best, most notably the GTA Series

Rockstar done good and planned the DLCs out very well

Good job rockstar

I think it's odd that Rockstar spent all that effort elsewhere only to dumb down the combat to virtual whack-a-mole

Thank you for this awesome game Rockstar

If you like rockstar or even GTA4 (even though its different, in a good way, this game deserves better than the "Grand Theft Horse" nickname it got), get this game.

With a addicting story, and "badass (my son saying)" character this game was a truly amazing Rockstar game

As a good rockstar games you can kill, thief, gamble, etc

Rockstar has finally broken their patten of over-the-top, offensive to be offensive games, and finally focused their efforts to produce a game that has the most moving story line I have seen this past decade.

Rockstar had outdone themselves with this game.

Rockstar has completely redeemed themselves with Red Dead Redemption

If you like other Rockstar games like "Bully" and "GTA4" this game is a must have.

Rockstar always had a knack for clever story written and character development and this game doesn't disappoint

Nice try R*. Next time.

If you get away then a bounty is put on your head, then you gotta watch out for bounty hunters.- You can play a few mini games of the ear such as Poker, Blackjack, Horseshoes, Liar's Dice, and a game called Five Finger Fillet (where you take a knife and stab between the fingers as fast as you can

It was a realistic, in a small sense as well as, in my own opinion, an unexpected ending

As well as take out your steed

It's basically designed to brainwash young people as they play.

I find myself climbing to a high point and enjoying the view at times, embarrassing as it sounds.

Nice try R*. Next time.