The black cartridge works OK but the color cartridge doesn't print red.

Black Cartridge worked fine

These cartridges work just as well as new and are so much cheaper

Works like they are original cartridges, and at a fraction of the cost

Says invalid cartridge

No low ink/counterfeit/missing cartridge errors

Great product works just as well as authentic printer cartridges

The cartridges work very well and I received them in a timely manner

The black cartridge only worked for a couple days.

Image 1 below is the last of the ink in my GENUINE HP cartridge before it ran out; Image 2 is the VALUETONER cartridge after a thorough cleaning of the printer

A pop up came up saying that the cartridge was defective.

Prints as well as virgin cartridges!

Yes, these aren't photo cartridges, but I can do that w/genuine HP cartridges,

Replaced cartridge, all is good.

The black cartridge stopped working after printing two sheets.

Black cartridge did not work, keep getting "black cartridge failure". unable to determine if color cartridge works or not

cartridges would not work in my HP printer no matter what I tried.

These cartridges work as promised with better than expected color and crisp black ink.

These work as well as the cartridges we pay $60+ for

The cartridge fit, but the black ink didn't work when used in my printer

I even have mismatching cartridges in my printer (a genuine HP color cartridge with a valuetoner black cartridge) and I’m still not having issues

My printer will no longer work at all because it is in "error mode" even when I take out the faulty cartridge

I ordered these cartridges for my HP Envy 4500 printer, and the color worked great

Bought this as a present & by the time we discovered it was the wrong cartridges it was to late to send back( 1 month had past).unable review product but return policy gets zero stars

The printer display reads replace faulty cartridges.

it's a genuine HP cartridge!

Placed new cartridge in printer and it worked very well

The cartridges did not work when I put them in my printer - printer wouldn't recognize them

These were the best ink cartridges I have ever purchased!

The black cartridge worked, but the color one did not.

I've purchased from other sellers and had the items come tossed in a plain Amazon bag with no instructions, unsealed, etc only to find out that they didn't work(was sold to me empty).So far, the cartridges work well with our printer

In the past, I bought 2 Black cartridges, one worked fine

I am not sure now if I do put the HP authentic cartridge if it will ever work again

Printer recognized the cartridges as previously used HP units and works fine

Valuetoner reached out to me and offered to replace the bad ink cartridge

I know that a pair of genuine HP XL cartridges would cost me 3x what these do, and that's even in Walmart!

Prints just as well as brand new HP cartridges

But, as I said, normally the cartridges are absolutely fine

Best remanufactured cartridges I've had.

The cartridges worked just like the HP ones and I liked the fact they recycle cartridges.

Perfect replacement cartridge and saving a lot of money to boot!!

No noticeable difference between these cartridges and genuine hp cartridges

and then it told me that they were used cartridges and they don't work at all.

One cartridge arrived leaking in its bag

Prompt shipping, cartridges work great, will reorder when needed.

My printer continued to say it was not the correct ink cartridge for this printer

the tricolor cartridge stopped working when it was still half full.

Cartridge became defective and wouldn’t function

I haven't tried the black cartridge since my printer isn't complaining about my old black cartridge.

Loved the bag sent to send in old cartridges free.

And knowing that I am recycling my old cartridges sits well with me

Unable to clear failed cartridge messages and unable to print anything

They worked great at first, but now just a few weeks later, I got an error message saying that my cartridges are incompatible and now its too late to return them!

Received both cartridges yesterday and they worked fine

Once the cartridge is declined I'm only offered -Shop Online-Cancel Print or Help

These cartridges plugged in and worked without any issuesThe printer sent a message saying recycled original cartridges were insertedNot much else to say except it's nice to save 75% and not have issues with the product

They look to be very good quality remanufactured ink cartridges just based on appearance alone

The printer recognized as a previously used genuine cartridge

As good as new cartridges.

Need to sent items back for correct cartridges.

the black cartridge worked but we are unable to get the colored ink to work..

Cartridge was missing the magenta ink

and I'll send my worthless cartridges to you!

The cartridge's work perfect for my printer

I have run the cartridge cleaner twice, but the printer status page I print does not change the hues

TThe cartridges are price very reasonable for someone who can't afford the cartridges that are for that printer that they have

The cartridges are reliable and perform perfectly.

I followed instructions ( reboot, cleaned contacts, etc.) but the faulty cartridge error always came up and it would not print like that

I had no problem with this product being rejected in my HP printer as "toner low, no toner installed or depleted cartridge detected" as w/otherremanufactured cartridges I have used previously

Works as great as name brand ink cartridges.

The ad claims that they are compatible with my HP Envy 4501 printer but the printer error message Incompatible Cartridge(s) will NOT allow me to use these.

No low ink/counterfeit/missing cartridge errors

The cartridges may work just fine, but my relatively-new HP printer would not use them

(We suffered several cartridges in a row that seemed empty after just a couple dozen pages of ordinary use.)

Excellent cartridges at a fantastic price, you won't go wrong buying and using them...

as good as or better than the original.

The ink is printing evenly and consistently, and no leaks, spills, or smears as with some others I've tried.