the toes were thrashed and full of holes by the end of the day and the inserts were sliding out of the shoe on all 3 pairs.

The only problem was if you bumped your toes at all on the rocks you could feel it pretty bad

My husband walked in these for a quarter of a mile on a sidewalk and the fabric where his toe is ripped

Most shoes hurt my toes but these don't.

It was a bit rough over the rocks, and the toes are definitely scuffed, but they held up surprisingly

I ended up taking out the inner sole as it kept bunching up and making my toes feel like they were falling off something.

Very comfy, fit is great, the only thing is that I wish there was more protective fabric over the Toe area, not to protect my toes, to extend the life of the water shoe

otherwise your toes will be right at the top of the shoe with no extra room to wiggle your toes.

But these shoes have such a stretchy upper fabric that they don't cramp my toes at all, and for that reason I love them.

The toes were a little looser than some water shoes I've had in the past but they never slipped off at the ankle (no mater if I was walking, in raft, or swimming)

I bought two pair for a recent vacation to 'Burning Man' and compared to the five toes shoes they worked for me greatly

The first hour of wearing these at a water park the toe ripped on top where my big toe is

The stretch on this does not in anyway bother my toes.

However, they were way too small and my toes were severely cramped

I only wear in the pool, not walking to and from, I do not have long/sharp toenails or drag toes on the pool floor, so I can't understand why.

The only thing I do not like about these shoes is that your feet always slide up and it makes for very uncomfortable toes

I am a true size 9, I put them on, and my toe was almost busting out.

For reference, my foot from heel to the tip of my great toe is right at 10.5 inches

Squeezes the toes too hard, really bad for those prone to ingrown toenails

I have wide toes and the rounded shape gives enough space that my toes are not squished together and do not hurt.

I got the 11-12 to be sure my toes don't graze the top and become uncomfortable

n’t hurting after walking for a while like with others

n’t hurting after walking for a while like with others

n’t do you much good with a hole in the side of the shoe