The tone, I think is prettier than the other whistles we have (Mel Bay), however, this is noticeably out of tune on a few if not all of the notes

It gives a nice bright tone, but starts to quiver when playing its very highest notes

It is harder to get a clear tone, especially on the second octave, than the Clarke Whistles.

The Fun & Colorful Tin Whistle - Key of C has a great sound & is easy for me to hold a good tone on both octaves.

The tone is great and it feels good in your hand

Excellent value for the price ($3.99), nice mellow tone, though a little more finicky than the Clarke when overblowing for the upper octave.

Good for practice, but not the best tone for recording