They have both broken and no longer work

No wear and tear, was only dropped once on to a carpet, aux port randomly stopped working at that really blows bc that’s the entire reason I bought this controller

Comfortable grip works fine

Comfortable, sleek design, generally works quite well and is Bluetooth compatible, which is awesome (works pretty well with a dongle)

It just quits working and breaks entirely.

Good quality, feels solid - works

The second one works well half of the time.

Got here fast works like a charm!

The controller was working great at first but just a couple months later it would not recognize my headset

Comfortable controller works great

The controller arrived in great condition and works just fine as of Jan/2018.

old 2 year controller still works fine but this one doesn't, haven't damaged it or had any other issues taking care of it, haven't played in a few weeks turn it on today and the audio is completely gone.other old controllers work just fine...not happy

My mic works perfectly fine in any other device, providing audio and microphone capabilities with no issues at all

I have one since 2 years ago that works, and I never damaged these controllers at all.

I am so upset that I bought my child a gift that doesn’t work work

Controller works well with XBOX One

Still smooth , all buttons worked properly

Was working really well until one the X button stopped working completely

Corded and Bluetooth connection standards work fine

Only works sometimes and other parts never worked, like the wired input,for

Got this for son and it is working great so far.

This one works great, just like the more expensive ones and even looks good sitting in the safe, (where the kids can't use, break it).

He says it works great and he likes this S version controller better than the original Xbox One controller he has for his Xbox One System because the Bluetooth works on both his laptop and Xbox One Gaming Console.

bought 2 of these for my kids work great, price wasn't crazy.

Controller has worked great.

A perfectly working product that I would recommend to anybody!

This controller has worked very well for me and my family, but I have had it for a far shorter time than my other controller, and the thumbsticks are already functioning improperly

This one works great, just like the more expensive ones and even looks good sitting in the safe, (where the kids can't use, break it).

Great controller --- works well -- no problems at all.