They both work great in terms of suctioning the milk out however this one I

Honestly I highly recommend it!I learned about this product from a social media group I'm in ( I had no prior knowledge that this existed until I was reading comments), and it has been a life saver

This was recommended to me by my doula and was a life saver at the beginning of my breastfeeding journey

I have one breast that is very painful the nurse from and my baby doesn’t like nursing from it so the haakaa has been a life saver

It really does help catch the leftover milk, as well as when I’m feeling a little too full it releases the pressure

So easy to use, and helps to bump up your supply when you're just breastfeeding

’s also helped me increase and stabilize my milk supply as well.

I ordered this because I have a rather plentiful milk supply and during the night hours especially my baby falls asleep

Not only does this avoid all of the milky messes, it helps you gain a decent supply of milk WITHOUT EVEN PUMPING

I now save the milk and have built up a great supply for when I go back to work and hubby has to feed her

I would also recommend purchasing the top to seal it once you’re done using it.. to avoid spillage!

It really does help catch the leftover milk, as well as when I’m feeling a little too full it releases the pressure

Perfect purchase for my sister who just had a baby and is breast-feeding

This is probably my favorite purchase from having a baby

I tried using this while nursing to get extra milk to store since it seemed easier to clean than a pump, but it didn’t work as

It really does help catch the leftover milk, as well as when I’m feeling a little too full it releases the pressure

I tried using this while nursing to get extra milk to store since it seemed easier to clean than a pump, but it didn’t work as

I now love the haakaa and consider it one of the most essential items I own

I tried using this while nursing to get extra milk to store since it seemed easier to clean than a pump, but it didn’t work as

It really does help catch the leftover milk, as well as when I’m feeling a little too full it releases the pressure

This worked great for catching the drip on one side while I’m breastfeeding on the other side.

It's so easy to clean, the suction works amazing and it cuts my pumping time in half

This works alright as a milk collector, but I do not recommend it as a pump of any kind

I would have loved if this worked for me because of the fact it’s all one piece, and seems so small, easy to conceal and clean.

But it does work well for the let down when im breast feeding.

This thing is AMAZING - to think I was loosing out on 2

n’t imagine how much milk I wasted in those three months

If you're a new breastfeeding mom, this will be the best thing you'll ever buy

The best thing i could have bought for ejectiom reflect milk...loving it!

this thing worked great, best to use as you are nursing to catch milk off opposite side you are feeding on

For me personally, this is a great product with excellent quality

I would like to be on the quality assurance team for this product to help fix the defects as this is such an important tool for breastfeeding with such horrible design flaws!

They both work great in terms of suctioning the milk out however this one I

Poor quality and expensive.

We were very excited to use this Product but unfortunately we will have to find a better quality item from a different brand.

n’t imagine how much milk I wasted in those three months

I always disliked pumping, so I could never build up a good stash of breastmilk

Easy and comfortable to use, helped me have a nice little freezer stash without using my electric pump

I was able to build up a nice little freezer stash just using my haakaa

I've been using this for about a month and have a very nice stash saved

It not only has great suction, but it does exactly what it is made to do!!

The only con I have is that the fuller it gets the more it loses suction

It holds great suction and I was most worried about that

It does lose suction after about 5 minutes so I just readjust it

The suction is good and this is very easy to use and clean

Great way to get extra milk out instead of letting it leak all over the place

For me I didn’t actually like the way I thought I would

It’s a fantastic and easy way to express milk while breastfeeding

admit I used it wrong for days and nearly gave up on it because the way I was using it hurt so bad

So easy to use, easy to clean, and a great way to capture milk while breastfeeding or on the go.

Always good to have a backup manual pump for when your electric pump is just too much fuss.

While the electric pump I use worked great, I LOVE to use my haakaa

I havent had to break out my electric pump because of this

I get more milk out with the Haaka than with my expensive electric pump

I love this breast pump to gather my leakage on the breast that I am not using to feed

Gave birth to first child four weeks ago, have a manual and electric breast pump, but my nipples were so sore after feeding and pumping that my midwife suggested the Haakaa

My skin must have been sticky because if the heat because once I was done with the pump, even I remove it slowly and carefully, it damaged my nipples (the very thin and sensitive skin on the areolas was cracked...)

Love that you can grab this and suction it to your free nipple when you are breast feeding and you waste no milk

Gentle on sore nipples yet strong enough to stay on the breast effortlessly and without worry if it falling off

If you have sensitive skin / breasts / nipples: save yourself the money, don't even attempt this

I have one breast that is very painful the nurse from and my baby doesn’t like nursing from it so the haakaa has been a life saver

I’ve literally attached it on the opposite breast (because it was leaking) while nursing and fallen asleep with it on

Super comfy, stands up to a decent amount of baby kicks if you have it attached well, and catches so much milk that would be otherwise lost to breast pads while nursing on the other side

I'm sure I would get more with another type of pump but considering you can put this on while you're already sitting and nursing, priceless.

Easy to use, great option for capturing leaking milk while nursing on the other breast and great for when breasts are full but baby is sleeping and you need just a bit of release.

A lot smoother than my last one

I had a lot of problems breast feeding but this sucked out more milk than my electric breast pump in minutes.

n’t stand the enough to wait

This is the coolest little tool, i cN’t recommend it enough

It does pinch a little, and it can pinch a lot when I squeeze it too tight, but it’s easy to fix

I have multiple bags of stored milk because of this bad boy!

but it's honestly probably not all that necessary if you have yourself prepared prior to putting these bad boys on

When I feed him, I just slap this bad boy on the other breast and just let it do it’s thang