The buttons are nice hard plastic

It's a cheaper plastic third part controller that works just fine for the Wii U.

That being said, the button layout is the same and the feel (other than the cheaper plastic) is the same

To me the plastic feels "cheaper" but I have no way of quantifying that

The plastic on the stick is VARY hard and hurts the fingers, so I'm giving up on that controller

The top material is hard, glossy plastic and bottom material is matte, hard plastic

Is made out of hard and thinner plastic when compared to the GameCube controller's admittedly higher quality materials.4

Holds really well but the plastic feels cheap

The analog sticks are fitted to the controller on flimsy plastic mounts that snapped in half during normal play

It seems to be made out of cheapy smooth slippery plastic, not as tough/well built as a regular game cube controller

I guess the only thing that could have been better would have been the shoulder buttons, they kind of have a kind of cheap plastic "springy" kind of effect to it when you press them, I think they could have been better

Very unhappy for a pretty piece of useless plastic!

Solid plastic although a little lightweight (beware ragequitters!

Very cheap plastic

The plastic feels a little cheap (especially the Z triggers), but altogether this controller is great

It's a cheaper plastic third part controller that works just fine for the Wii U.

The buttons are nice hard plastic

The Hori one's feel like there's a flat piece of cheap plastic there that barely moves

The buttons are responsive and the L and R buttons are nice and clicky

The axises on the left stick are extremely unreliable, inputs were sometimes even reversed, the L and R triggers act like gamecube triggers but don't register anything until being pushed in all the way, the list of problems just goes on

Works as it should.

Maybe I'm being picky, and I only gave one star off for it, but IMO you just should not have to depress a